Halloween may still be over a month away, but one couple’s first dance to “I Put a Spell on You” by Screaming Jay Hawkins will leave you utterly bewitched!

Justin Willman and Jillian Sipkins got married on September 6th in Malibu, California, and the groom, a magician, treated guests to mind-blowing tricks during their spin on the dance floor. (If the newlyweds look familiar, it’s because they also went viral recently with their hilarious “Drunk History” story of how they met, proving they’re having the most insane wedding week ever.)

Watch their spooky and sexy waltz (choreographed by friend Sebastien Stella) and try not to freak out during the finale:

Was that not the coolest thing you’ve ever seen at a wedding or what? P.S. The adorable guy jumping up in the background was the groom’s dad, who posted the following image to Imgur, where it has over 1,893,842 views (and counting).

Photo Credit: datmeta on Imgur

— Stefania Sainato